localnews.ie

Patrick Quirke granted Supreme Court appeal over Bobby Ryan murder conviction

By Saoirse Doyle

Historic decision · Decision date:

The court will examine two issues from his trial: what a search warrant application must say about the evidence sought, and the prosecution's discretion over calling expert witnesses.

The Supreme Court has granted Patrick Quirke leave to appeal his murder conviction. The determination was delivered on 26 April 2022. Dunne J., Woulfe J. and Hogan J. made the decision.

Mr Quirke is a dairy farmer from Breanshamore, County Tipperary. He was convicted in the Central Criminal Court of murdering Bobby Ryan. The jury's verdict was by a majority of 10 to 2. The trial lasted 71 days. He was sentenced to life imprisonment.

The Court of Appeal dismissed his appeal against conviction on 16 November 2021. He had advanced 52 grounds there. Two of them now go to the Supreme Court.

The first concerns the search warrant for his home. The sworn information did not mention computers. It referred to "any other evidence". Gardaí seized a computer. The trial judge ruled the warrant valid. The Court of Appeal called the omission "sub-optimal" but not fatal.

The second concerns pathology evidence. Different pathologists agreed that Mr Ryan died of blunt force trauma. They differed on the likely cause. The defence asked the trial judge to have the prosecution call one expert. She refused. The defence called him itself. The Court of Appeal found no basis to interfere.

The Director of Public Prosecutions opposed leave. The search warrant point was factual, it said. The pathology evidence arose in unusual circumstances.

The Supreme Court disagreed. It found two matters of general public importance. One is how far a warrant application must identify what is to be searched for. The other is the extent of the prosecution's discretion over which witnesses to call, especially experts. The court said the issues may arise in other criminal trials. Further clarity would be in the public interest.

The issues may be refined at case management.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal