localnews.ie

Yusuf Ali Abdi miscarriage of justice certificate case: DPP granted Supreme Court appeal

By Cathal Brosnan

Historic decision · Decision date:

The Director of Public Prosecutions will argue about the meaning of acquittal and miscarriage of justice, after a verdict of not guilty by reason of insanity.

The Supreme Court granted the Director of Public Prosecutions leave on 14 January 2022 to appeal from the Court of Appeal, in an application by Yusuf Ali Abdi under section 9 of the Criminal Procedure Act 1993. Section 9 provides for compensation for a miscarriage of justice.

Mr Abdi was convicted of the murder of his 20-month-old son on 23 May 2003, after a jury rejected his defence of insanity. His appeal against that verdict was dismissed.

In 2013, while serving his sentence, he was diagnosed with paranoid schizophrenia. He applied under section 2 of the 1993 Act, on the basis that the diagnosis was a newly-discovered fact, and the Court of Appeal quashed the conviction and ordered a retrial.

At the retrial in December 2019, all the forensic psychiatric evidence accepted that he had been suffering from schizophrenia at the time. The jury returned a verdict of not guilty by reason of insanity.

Mr Abdi then sought a certificate under section 9. Owens J. in the High Court held that such a verdict amounts to an acquittal and that there had been a miscarriage of justice. The Court of Appeal, in a judgment by Birmingham P., upheld the certificate.

The DPP argued that a changed medical diagnosis many years later should not entitle a person to a certificate, and that the Court of Appeal decision created uncertainty. Mr Abdi opposed leave.

The Supreme Court found a matter of general public importance on the meaning of "acquittal" in section 9, and on the meaning of "miscarriage of justice" and whether it covers this situation.

The judges were MacMenamin J., Dunne J. and Hogan J.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal