The Supreme Court has refused John Maher permission to appeal in a case brought by the Director of Public Prosecutions at the suit of Garda David Costigan. The determination was delivered on 14 April 2022.
The case concerns a burglary in Drimnagh, Dublin, on 12 November 2010. A blood sample recovered from the scene was sent to the Forensic Science Laboratory in the Phoenix Park, which generated a DNA profile. Mr Maher was arrested on 12 September 2016 and a sample was taken from him. He does not challenge the taking of that sample.
His argument was that the crime scene profile should not have been retained and so could not lawfully be matched to him. He said that keeping DNA profiles on a computer required statutory authority.
District Judge Gráinne Malone asked the High Court for its opinion. Meenan J. accepted Mr Maher's arguments on 3 March 2020. The Court of Appeal reversed that ruling on 3 August 2021, holding that nothing had prohibited generating, keeping and matching the samples.
The DPP said the case was now spent, that there are very few such samples gathered before the 2014 Act commenced, and that the proposed appeal raised nothing of general public interest.
The Supreme Court said Mr Maher had not shown that the Court of Appeal's analysis was incorrect. It also found no constitutional ground to exclude a blood sample lawfully taken at a crime scene. Charleton J., O'Malley J. and Murray J. refused leave.