The Supreme Court has refused Vieira Ltd permission to appeal against a Court of Appeal ruling in its VAT dispute with the Inspector of Taxes. The determination was delivered on 5 April 2022.
Vieira is a building development company that built a large housing development in Tyrellstown, Co. Dublin, in the early 2000s. It signed licence agreements for 198 nearly completed houses with the selling agent, McPeake Auctioneers, and accounted for VAT on them as a self-supply. It did not account for VAT on the later sales of the houses to consumers. Revenue then assessed it for almost €2 million in VAT on sales in 2003 and 2004.
Circuit Court Judge Linnane asked the High Court for its opinion on two questions of law. Costello J. found that the agreements were neither a letting nor a surrender of possession, and that they amounted to an abuse of rights. The Court of Appeal agreed and also saw no basis for a reference to the Court of Justice of the EU.
Vieira said the appeal raised points of general public importance and asked the Supreme Court to make a reference to the EU court. The Supreme Court disagreed. It said the lower courts had applied established case law and that the claim of error was not substantiated.
MacMenamin J., Dunne J. and Woulfe J. refused leave.