localnews.ie

Geraldine Scanlon refused Supreme Court appeal in Grant Thornton confidential data case

By Donal Gilhooly

Historic decision · Decision date:

The dispute began when Grant Thornton sent her a compact disc in answer to a data access request that also held other people's confidential information.

The Supreme Court refused Geraldine Scanlon leave to appeal in her long-running case with Grant Thornton on 29 March 2022. The application was brought by Ms Scanlon, who represented herself, against a Court of Appeal decision.

The case began in November 2015, when she made a data protection access request to Grant Thornton. The firm sent her a compact disc that also held confidential and personal data of unconnected third parties and the firm's own proprietary information. She refused to return it and accepted she had copied and shared the material. Grant Thornton and Grant Thornton Corporate Finance Limited sued for breach of confidence and sought injunctions.

By the time of the High Court ruling there had been eleven interlocutory applications, around 40 affidavits and 70 listings. Pilkington J. struck out the "sequencing" and "jurisdiction" motions, the latter being Ms Scanlon's argument that the claim belonged before the Data Protection Commissioner. She also struck out parts of her defence and counterclaim. The Court of Appeal upheld that, varying the order slightly.

The Supreme Court extended time for the application because Ms Scanlon was a litigant in person and the firms did not object. It refused applications by several people to intervene, because they concentrated on the facts of the case.

It said the case turned on well-established principles of the High Court's jurisdiction and its own facts. She had already had a full hearing and a full appeal. O'Donnell C.J., Charleton J. and Woulfe J. refused leave.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal