The Supreme Court has refused John McCormack permission to appeal in his case with the Criminal Assets Bureau, in a determination delivered on 4 March 2022. The court said his arguments raised no issue of general public importance.
Mr McCormack applied for leave to appeal from the Court of Appeal. That court had dismissed his appeal against a High Court order made by Owens J. under section 3 of the Proceeds of Crime Act 1996. The order restrained him, and anyone with notice of it, from disposing of or dealing with a number of named properties.
He raised three points. The first was that his wife and adult daughter live in some of the properties, so the Bureau should have joined them to the proceedings. The second was that evidence of belief from a senior garda was "hearsay upon hearsay". The third was that refusing him legal aid made the proceedings unfair.
The Supreme Court said the notice argument "appears misconceived". It said the High Court had admitted evidence of belief under settled law, and that the legal aid question had been fully considered below.
The judges, O'Donnell C.J., Charleton J. and Baker J., said the case raised no issue of general public importance and an appeal was not needed in the interests of justice. The application was dismissed.