localnews.ie

Pembroke Road Association granted Supreme Court appeal in An Bord Pleanála apartments case

By Rory Hanlon

Historic decision · Decision date:

The Supreme Court allowed a direct appeal on three issues, including how a strategic housing regulation is read and whether the Board can correct a defect after a High Court ruling.

The Supreme Court granted Pembroke Road Association leave to appeal directly from the High Court in its challenge to An Bord Pleanála, in a determination delivered on 1 March 2022. MacMenamin J., Dunne J. and Hogan J. made the decision.

The association had challenged the Board's decision to grant permission for a development including apartments in Dublin 4. In the High Court, Owens J. rejected its argument that the application lacked a statement required by Article 299B of the Planning and Development Regulations 2001.

Before Owens J. gave judgment, but after the hearing, Humphreys J. delivered judgment in the Waltham Abbey Residents Association case. He reached the opposite view and held that the statement had to be a separate document.

Owens J. found that condition 26 of the permission was ultra vires and could not be severed. He did not quash the decision. He adjourned the proceedings so the Board could amend it under section 146A of the Planning and Development Act 2000. He also held it was "self-evident" that the objectives of the plan did not align with the National Planning Framework, in the context of the Building Height Guidelines 2018.

The association asked to appeal on all three issues. The Board did not oppose leave on the interpretation of Article 299B or on its power to amend under section 146A. It opposed leave on the Building Height Guidelines.

The Supreme Court said two differing High Court interpretations created exceptional circumstances and a matter of general public importance. It noted that the Court of Appeal had listed this appeal and the Waltham Abbey appeal for 11 October 2022. It found the constitutional threshold met for each of the three issues.

The Waltham Abbey case was also granted leave. The court plans to have both cases case managed by the same judge and heard as quickly as possible.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal