localnews.ie

Supreme Court to hear An Bord Pleanála appeal in Waltham Abbey Residents Association case

By Cathal Brosnan

Historic decision · Decision date:

The court agreed to a direct appeal from the High Court over how a planning regulation for strategic housing developments should be read, and plans to have it heard as quickly as possible.

The Supreme Court has granted An Bord Pleanála leave to appeal directly from the High Court in its case with Waltham Abbey Residents Association. The determination was delivered on 1 March 2022 by MacMenamin J., Dunne J. and Hogan J.

The case concerns permission the Board granted for apartments in Ballincollig. The residents' association took proceedings in the High Court, challenging among other things non-compliance with regulation 299B of the Planning and Development Regulations 2001.

Humphreys J. held that the regulation requires a distinct, identifiable document to be submitted as part of an application for a strategic housing development. He concluded that the Board's decision was invalid because no such document had been submitted.

The Board then applied for leave to appeal. Humphreys J. granted permission to appeal on one question: whether the word "statement" in the regulation means a distinct identifiable document, which could include a distinct statement within a larger document.

The Board told the Supreme Court that the law was uncertain because Owens J. had not followed Humphreys J.'s interpretation in a separate High Court judgment a month later. It said 19 judicial review applications were waiting on the issue and asked for a priority hearing. The residents' association did not oppose the application.

The Supreme Court said the conflicting High Court judgments meant the issue was of general public importance and in the interests of justice. It also found exceptional circumstances for a direct appeal. The question is a single point of statutory interpretation and would not change if it went first to the Court of Appeal.

The court said the need for speed outweighed the benefit of a Court of Appeal judgment. It plans to have the appeal case managed and then heard as quickly as possible.

The related application in Pembroke Road Association v An Bord Pleanála was decided on the same day.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal