localnews.ie

Ronald Krikke and others granted Supreme Court appeal over Waterford wind turbines

By Rory Hanlon

Historic decision · Decision date:

Residents challenge a Court of Appeal ruling that let a Ballyduff wind farm keep turbines with 103-metre rotor blades, where the 2011 permission described 90 metres.

The Supreme Court granted Ronald Krikke, Pia Umans, Sean Harris, Catherine Harris, Patrick Kenneally, Caroline Kenneally and Kenneth Geary leave on 28 February 2022 to appeal from the Court of Appeal. The dispute concerns turbines at a wind farm in the townland of Ballyduff, County Waterford, operated by Barranafaddock Sustainable Electricity Limited.

An Bord Pleanála granted planning permission for the wind farm in 2005. In 2011, the company applied to modify it, and the application described rotor blades 90 metres in diameter. The planning authority granted permission in November 2011, with a condition that details of the turbines be agreed before work began.

In November 2013, the company's consultants made a compliance submission. A drawing in it showed rotor blades of 103 metres. In December 2013, the planning authority replied "noted and agreed" under that condition.

The company built turbines with 103-metre blades, and they became operational in 2015. In May 2018, the planning authority referred the question to the Board after complaints from residents. In December 2018, the Board declared that the change was development and was not exempted development.

The residents then sought a planning injunction in the High Court. On 6 December 2019, Simons J. decided that the turbines as built were not authorised, and restrained their use for the time being.

On 30 July 2021, the Court of Appeal allowed the company's appeal. It held that the Board could not decide that development was unauthorised, and that the December 2013 letter agreed the change. It added that the residents could have challenged that decision in time by judicial review.

The Supreme Court found matters of general public importance on the effect of an agreement under a condition leaving points of detail open, including public participation and environmental impact assessment. It also found them on the scope of the Board's declaration. It said they may arise in other cases.

The grounds may be refined in case management. The judges were O'Malley J., Baker J. and Woulfe J.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal