localnews.ie

Friends of the Irish Environment granted Supreme Court appeal over Project Ireland 2040 plans

By Rory Hanlon

Historic decision · Decision date:

The appeal covers three issues under the Strategic Environmental Assessment Directive, which the Supreme Court has never previously considered.

The Supreme Court granted Friends of the Irish Environment CLG leave on 21 February 2022 to appeal from the Court of Appeal, in its challenge to a Government decision of May 2018 on Project Ireland 2040, which comprises the National Planning Framework and the National Development Plan.

The environmental organisation took a judicial review against the Government of Ireland, the Minister for Housing, Planning and Local Government, Ireland and the Attorney General. Barr J. dismissed the application in the High Court on 24 April 2020.

On 26 November 2021, the Court of Appeal affirmed that decision, save for one issue that is no longer relevant. Costello J. delivered the judgment, with Haughton J. and Murray J. on the panel.

The organisation applied to the Supreme Court on 4 January 2022. It argued that the Strategic Environmental Assessment Directive requires the selected option and the reasonable alternatives to receive the same level of analysis, whereas the alternatives were given only cursory assessment. The Court of Appeal had found the assessment comparable.

It also raised the monitoring of significant environmental effects under Article 10 of the Directive, which the Court of Appeal said was more likely to arise at the level of individual projects. A third issue was whether the National Development Plan is a free-standing budgetary plan, outside the Directive.

The respondents disputed that any issue of general public importance arose, and supported the Court of Appeal's reasoning.

The Supreme Court found that all three issues are matters of general public importance. It pointed to the huge level of public capital investment envisaged by the plan, and to the fact that it has never considered the Directive's parameters. It said the issues are in many respects novel and important.

The grounds may be refined at case management. The judges were MacMenamin J., Dunne J. and Hogan J.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal