The Supreme Court on 21 December 2022 refused former Decobake director Paul Coyle leave to appeal against a Court of Appeal decision in the liquidation of the company.
Mr Coyle had lost an appeal in the Court of Appeal on 13 October 2021, where Mr Justice Haughton dismissed his challenge to the High Court's approval of liquidator Declan De Lacy's fees and its refusal of discovery. Mr De Lacy opposed leave.
Mr Coyle asked the Supreme Court to set aside the Court of Appeal orders and send the matters back to the High Court. He argued that being refused discovery breached the equality of arms, that the courts had not fully accommodated his dyslexia, and that his property rights had been interfered with.
The Supreme Court panel of Mr Justice Charleton, Ms Justice Baker and Mr Justice Hogan found that his grounds were tied to the specific facts of his case and were complaints that the lower courts had got it wrong.
It found no inequality of arms and no issue of general public importance. It also said an appeal was not necessary in the interests of justice, and refused leave.