The Supreme Court has refused Imre Arakas leave to appeal against a High Court order for his surrender to Lithuania, in a determination delivered on 16 December 2022.
Mr Arakas was the applicant. On 7 November 2022 the High Court (Mr Justice Burns) ordered his surrender on two European Arrest Warrants. The first referred to offences the judge found corresponded to murder, unlawful possession of firearms and criminal damage under Irish law. The second was based on the same domestic warrant and the same investigation. On 30 November 2022 he applied to the Supreme Court directly, without first seeking a certificate to appeal to the Court of Appeal.
He had first argued that no decision had been made to charge and try him. After further information arrived from the Lithuanian authority, and in light of the Supreme Court's decision in Minister for Justice and Equality v Campbell, that argument was not pressed. He then argued that the additional information disclosed a different offence. The High Court rejected that, holding that his alleged role in the murder had only been clarified.
The Supreme Court panel of Chief Justice O'Donnell, Ms Justice O'Malley and Mr Justice Murray found that no point of law of general public importance arose. It said Mr Arakas had pointed to no specific error in the High Court's assessment of the evidence, and that his claims that his lawyers had ignored his instructions had no stated basis. Leave was refused.