The Supreme Court has granted Gary McAreavey leave to appeal against his conviction for assisting an offender, in a determination delivered on 16 December 2022.
Mr McAreavey applied for leave to appeal after the Court of Appeal upheld his conviction on 28 July 2022. The Special Criminal Court had convicted him. His co-accused, Caolan Smyth, was convicted in the same trial of attempted murder and of possessing a firearm with intent to endanger life. Both men appealed to the Court of Appeal, which dealt with the two appeals in a single judgment.
The Supreme Court described the case against the two men. Mr Smyth was convicted of shooting at a man with intent to kill. Mr McAreavey was found to have bought petrol to destroy the car Mr Smyth had used.
Two issues arise. The first is shared by both men and concerns whether certain evidence derived from retained telephony data was admissible. That evidence was used to connect Mr McAreavey with his co-accused. The court had already granted Mr Smyth leave on that issue in a separate determination.
The second issue is specific to Mr McAreavey. It concerns section 7(2) of the Criminal Law Act 1997, which makes it an offence to assist a person who has committed an arrestable offence, knowing or believing that person to be guilty of that offence or of some other arrestable offence. The prosecution's position at trial was that it did not have to identify the other arrestable offence if it could not prove knowledge of the main one. The defence argued that an alternative offence had to be specified if the prosecution relied on one.
The trial court found it probable, but not proven, that Mr McAreavey knew precisely what his co-accused had been doing. It nonetheless read the Act as allowing the prosecution to prove knowledge or belief of either the specific offence or some other, unspecified arrestable offence. The Court of Appeal agreed with that reading.
The Supreme Court panel of Chief Justice O'Donnell, Ms Justice O'Malley and Mr Justice Murray decided to grant leave on the telephony data issue, for the reasons given in the Smyth determination. It was also satisfied that the second issue raises questions of law of general public importance, and granted leave on that too.