localnews.ie

Caolan Smyth granted Supreme Court appeal over phone data used in attempted murder conviction

By Aoife Loughran

Historic decision · Decision date:

The Special Criminal Court convicted him over a May 2017 shooting at a petrol station, and the Court of Appeal upheld the verdict.

The Supreme Court on 16 December 2022 granted Caolan Smyth leave to appeal his convictions for attempted murder and possession of a firearm with intent to endanger life.

The panel was O'Donnell C.J., O'Malley J. and Murray J. The Court of Appeal upheld the convictions on 28 July 2022.

The charges arose from an incident in May 2017. A man was shot in the neck by the driver of a car at a petrol station. Mr Smyth was alleged to be the shooter. The car was later found burnt out, and his co-accused, Gary McAreavey, was charged with assisting in its destruction.

The trial was heard in the Special Criminal Court and lasted for much of the Michaelmas term in 2020. The prosecution relied partly on retained telephony data. It used the data to attribute an unregistered phone to Mr Smyth and to track the car through cell sites. The data was kept under the Communications (Retention of Data) Act 2011.

The defence relied on European case law on data retention and on access to retained data. At the time, a senior garda officer decided applications for access, with no independent or judicial oversight. The trial court found that Mr Smyth's rights had not been breached. It also found that a different system would not have produced a different result.

The Court of Appeal endorsed that analysis. The Court of Justice of the European Union delivered its judgment in Dwyer on 5 April 2022, holding that the Irish statute did not comply with EU law. Mr Smyth says the evidence was obtained in breach of Irish and EU law and that oversight cannot be sidestepped by speculating about another outcome.

The Supreme Court said the case arises against a complex legal background involving the Constitution, EU law and the 2011 Act. It held that these matters give rise to issues of law of general public importance.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal