Eugene McCool has been refused leave to appeal to the Supreme Court against a summary judgment of €228,005.36 obtained by ACC Loan Management Company DAC and Cabot Financial (Ireland) Limited. The decision was delivered on 25 November 2022 by Charleton J., Baker J. and Hogan J.
The High Court, Reynolds J., granted the summary judgment. On 24 June 2021, the Court of Appeal dismissed Mr McCool's appeal. It rejected three arguments: that a 20-year mortgage had been wrongly converted into a 2-year bridging facility, that his accounts had been mismanaged, and that the appointment of a receiver had worsened his finances.
Mr McCool told the Supreme Court that his two appeals were listed on the same day, although he had no lawyer, and that this gave the other side a litigation advantage. The company said he attended case management hearings and did not oppose that listing.
The Supreme Court said the principles on summary judgment are well established and no new ground had been identified. It said his complaints about the receiver and the loans were vague, specific to the facts, and raised no point of general importance. The receiver was not part of the summary judgment application.
The court added that he could have asked for separate days and did not, so his unfairness argument came too late. It said an extension of time would have been refused. Leave was refused.