Bridget Delaney has been granted leave to appeal directly from the High Court to the Supreme Court in her challenge to the Personal Injuries Guidelines. Charleton J., Hogan J. and Murray J. made the decision on 25 November 2022. The respondents are the Personal Injuries Assessment Board (PIAB), the Judicial Council, Ireland and the Attorney General.
Ms Delaney claims she was injured in an accident on 12 April 2019, through the negligence of Waterford City and County Council. She applied to PIAB on 4 June 2019. Her application had not been decided when the Judicial Council adopted the guidelines in March 2021.
From April 2021, PIAB was required to have regard to the guidelines when deciding claims. In May 2021 it decided her application by reference to them, not the Book of Quantum that they replaced.
Ms Delaney argued that the guidelines hand legislative power to the Judicial Council and undermine judicial independence. She said they apply retrospectively and that the reductions they make in awards are disproportionate or irrational. She also said her claim pre-dated the guidelines and should have been assessed under the Book of Quantum.
Meenan J. rejected all of her claims in the High Court. He held that she was entitled to have her damages assessed under the law as it stands on the date of assessment, not to a particular sum.
PIAB, Ireland and the Attorney General accepted that the case is of general public importance and that a direct appeal is warranted. The Judicial Council took a neutral position.
The Supreme Court said the claim raises significant questions about delegated legislation, judicial independence and the separation of powers between the judiciary and the Oireachtas. It also may raise an issue about two constitutional tests used in reviewing legislation, from Heaney v. Ireland and Tuohy v. Courtney. It will hold an early case management hearing.