Noreen Stafford has been granted leave to appeal directly from the High Court to the Supreme Court in a possession case brought by Start Mortgages DAC. MacMenamin J., O'Malley J. and Hogan J. made the decision on 22 November 2022. The court also extended time for her application.
Start Mortgages applied in the Circuit Court for an order for possession of property on foot of a mortgage. The two sides dispute the validity of the mortgage documentation. The court heard that Ms Stafford has represented herself in the proceedings.
The Circuit Court heard the case in May 2019. The judge was dissatisfied with some of the proofs and directed Start Mortgages to file a further affidavit on how the mortgage documents were executed. The case was adjourned to October 2019, and the court heard no further affidavit was ever filed, despite further adjournments.
In May 2020, Ms Stafford issued a motion to strike out the proceedings. On 4 November 2020 the Circuit Court judge struck them out, after counsel for Start Mortgages admitted there had been delay in swearing an affidavit.
Start Mortgages appealed to the High Court, where the case was presented as an appeal against a refusal of an adjournment. The High Court allowed the appeal and sent the matter back to the Circuit Court, directing Start Mortgages to file an affidavit within three weeks. Ms Stafford applied to the Supreme Court on 19 August 2021.
The Supreme Court said it was concerned that the High Court may not have been told the Circuit Court judge had begun a substantive hearing. It also raised a question over the High Court's jurisdiction to remit a matter in such circumstances. It held that this raises a question of general public importance, and granted leave on that question and in the interests of justice.
The court noted that Ms Stafford is willing to use its voluntary representation scheme and should contact the Registrar immediately. Revised grounds of appeal must be lodged by 11 January 2023.