localnews.ie

Promontoria (Oyster) granted Supreme Court appeal in Fergus O'Connor farmland insolvency case

By Donal Gilhooly

Historic decision · Decision date:

The creditor says the Wexford farmer's land is worth more than the roughly €1.1 million he owes it, and the court will decide what counts as a readily realisable asset.

Promontoria (Oyster) DAC has been granted leave to appeal directly to the Supreme Court in a personal insolvency case involving Fergus O'Connor of Ballygarron, Kilmuckridge, County Wexford. MacMenamin J., Dunne J. and Woulfe J. made the decision on 22 November 2022. The appeal goes straight from the High Court.

Mr O'Connor asked the Circuit Court to approve a personal insolvency arrangement to settle his debts. Promontoria is owed approximately €1.1 million by him and objected. It argued that his farmland exceeded the value of the debt, so selling it would repay the money and he was not insolvent.

Judge Enright held in the Circuit Court that Mr O'Connor was insolvent and that his agricultural land was not a "readily realisable asset". Owens J. agreed on appeal to the High Court. He held that farmland would take a considerable time to sell, and that forcing a sale would cost Mr O'Connor his livelihood. The land was therefore excluded under section 99 of the 2012 Act.

Promontoria told the Supreme Court that the ruling could affect how creditors recover debts from anyone who holds agricultural land above the debt owed. It said it cannot appeal to the Court of Appeal because of section 39 of the Courts of Justice Act 1936. Mr O'Connor opposed leave. He said the ruling was limited to its facts and that Promontoria would be paid in full.

The Supreme Court held that the issue meets the threshold of exceptional circumstances for a further appeal. It turns on the meaning of "readily realisable asset" in the Personal Insolvency Act 2012, in particular section 99(1)(d). The issue can be refined in case management.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal