Angela Redic has been refused leave to appeal directly to the Supreme Court in her case against Tusla, the Legal Aid Board, the Office of the Ombudsman and the Garda Commissioner. The decision was delivered on 16 November 2022 by Charleton J., Baker J. and Hogan J.
In 2021, Ms Redic was involved in family law cases in six District Courts, later appealed to three Circuit Courts. She made ten applications to the Board for legal aid certificates. It granted two certificates.
She then went to the High Court seeking an order of mandamus compelling the Board to issue certificates on her seventh and tenth applications. Meenan J. refused the application on 21 February 2022. He noted that Bolger J. had reached the same conclusion because Ms Redic did not meet the statutory requirements for legal aid.
Ms Redic's complaint to the Supreme Court was mainly about delay by the Board, which she said forced her to represent herself against represented respondents. Her application was one month out of time, but the court would have extended time.
It held that access to justice does not require public funds for legal representation in every kind of case. Even if the Board delayed, it said, that did not amount to the exceptional circumstances needed for a direct appeal, and the issues were fact specific. Any appeal of this kind should go first to the Court of Appeal.