localnews.ie

Revenue granted Supreme Court appeal over Dominos Pizza delivery drivers' tax status

By Cathal Brosnan

Historic decision · Decision date:

The appeal against Karshan Midlands Ltd, which trades as Dominos Pizza, will decide whether its drivers in Athlone, Mullingar and Tullamore were employees or independent contractors for tax.

The Revenue Commissioners have been granted leave to appeal to the Supreme Court in a tax case against Karshan Midlands Ltd, which trades as Dominos Pizza. The decision was delivered on 4 November 2022 by Charleton J, Baker J and Hogan J. The appeal is against a Court of Appeal decision of 31 May 2022.

The case concerns delivery drivers at retail outlets in Athlone, Mullingar and Tullamore. The question is whether they were independent contractors or employees under contracts of service. That status decides how they are taxed under the Taxes Consolidation Act 1997.

The Appeal Commissioners found the drivers were employees, and referred questions of law to the High Court by way of case stated. O'Connor J held in favour of the Revenue on all points. He found that mutuality of obligation could arise under an umbrella contract.

Karshan appealed to the Court of Appeal. By a majority, with Whelan J dissenting, that court held that the Commissioners and the High Court had erred. Costello J said the central question was whether the driver was obliged to perform work, and the contract imposed no such obligation. Whelan J would have found a contract of service.

The Revenue Commissioners argued that the case raises points of general public importance, including whether mutuality of obligation applies to umbrella contracts. They said it would be the first major case on employment status in the Supreme Court since Henry Denny & Sons (Ireland) Ltd v Minister for Social Welfare. Karshan opposed leave and said the case turned on its own facts and concerned payments from 2010 and 2011.

The Supreme Court accepted that issues of general public importance arise. It said they go beyond a discrete issue of tax payments from 2010 and 2011, and it noted that it has not yet clarified the law for workers engaged under contracts like those used by Karshan.

The issues for appeal, subject to refinement, are how to construe umbrella contracts where work is paid by the task, and the criteria for self-employed or employee tax treatment.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal