Brian McDonagh has been refused leave to appeal to the Supreme Court in his case with Ulster Bank Ireland DAC. The decision was delivered on 25 October 2022. The court said he had been given a fair hearing in the Court of Appeal.
Mr McDonagh's appeal concerned a small correction. In July 2021, Twomey J. amended the bank's title in a High Court judgment from "Ulster Bank DAC" to "Ulster Bank Ireland DAC". That judgment found the bank was entitled to €22 million from Mr McDonagh and his two brothers over the purchase of a site in Wicklow.
The Court of Appeal dismissed his challenge to the correction on 8 November 2021. He argued that the court had decided the appeal in advance, because it rose for 14 minutes before giving its ruling. He also complained that it refused an adjournment so he could get the digital audio recording of the hearing.
The Supreme Court said nothing suggested the matter was predetermined. Judges read papers in advance, it said, and familiarity with the case "furthers the fairness of a hearing".
It said a court may refuse to adjourn a hearing already begun. It also said the rulings below were "measured, comprehensive, and showed ample engagement with the arguments made by both sides". MacMenamin J., Dunne J. and Woulfe J. refused leave.