Keith Connorton has been granted leave to appeal to the Supreme Court against his conviction for the murder of Graham McKeever. Mr Connorton, who shared a house in Tallaght, County Dublin, with the main witness, was found guilty in the Central Criminal Court by a 10:2 majority on 21 December 2018. He was sentenced to life imprisonment. MacMenamin J., Dunne J. and Woulfe J. made the decision on 24 October 2022.
The trial heard that Mr McKeever had been invited to the house by Mr Connorton's former partner, Ciara McGrath, in December 2017. Mr Connorton returned in the early hours, and an altercation followed in the kitchen. Mr McKeever died at the scene.
Two emergency calls were made after the stabbing. Ms McGrath gave evidence that she made a 999 call. The other, to 112, was made by Mr Connorton. At trial, Mr Connorton argued the 999 call should be excluded under the rule against hearsay. The trial judge let it in as part of the res gestae, meaning the events of the night.
The Court of Appeal dismissed Mr Connorton's appeal on this point in October 2021. It agreed the call was admissible, though not for the trial judge's reasons. It said clearer reasons might have been given, but the judge was ultimately correct.
Mr Connorton applied to the Supreme Court in July 2022. He argued that the Court of Appeal was wrong to admit the call, because it looked only at the timing of the call and not at the danger that the statement was fabricated. He asked for a priority hearing.
The Director of Public Prosecutions did not oppose leave but disagreed that the constitutional threshold was met. She argued that modern technology has outstripped the hearsay rule and that a further exception should cover evidence of the highest quality, such as the 999 call. She also asked for a priority hearing.
The Supreme Court held that the admissibility of recordings of emergency calls, and the basis for it, are matters of general public importance likely to arise in other cases. The issues can be refined in case management if necessary.