Anthony J. Fitzpatrick has been refused leave to appeal to the Supreme Court in his challenge to three certificates of taxation issued by Paul M. Behan, Taxing Master of the High Court. The decision was delivered on 30 September 2022. The court said the High Court and the Court of Appeal had applied well-settled law to the facts of the case.
Mr Fitzpatrick said the Taxing Master was objectively biased. He relied on three points: the cost accountants for Myles Kirby, the notice party, were Behan & Associates, the Taxing Master's former firm. He was the registered owner of that business name. And before 2017 he had been landlord of the premises it occupied.
The High Court refused to quash the certificates. The Court of Appeal upheld that decision. It said the former connection with the firm was not objective bias, given the limited number of cost accountants practising in the State.
The Supreme Court noted that Mr Fitzpatrick's application was filed on 14 April 2021 and that the leave booklet had not been filed. It said it could have dismissed the application on that ground, but decided to deal with it on the merits.
O'Donnell C.J., Charleton J. and Hogan J. said no novel point of general public importance arose. They said it was not suggested that the law on objective bias is unclear, and that an appeal was not in the interests of justice. The application was dismissed.