localnews.ie

Ciarán Davitt cannabis case: DPP granted Supreme Court appeal over garda right of audience

By Eimear Byrne

Historic decision · Decision date:

The Director of Public Prosecutions is appealing a High Court ruling that a sergeant had no right to prosecute a District Court case in place of the prosecuting garda.

The Director of Public Prosecutions has been granted leave to appeal to the Supreme Court in a case involving Ciarán Davitt, who was charged with possession of cannabis. The decision was delivered on 12 September 2022 by Dunne J., Baker J. and Murray J. The appeal goes directly from the High Court.

Mr Davitt's case was being prosecuted by Garda Liam Varley. On the return date, Garda Varley did not appear and no solicitor from the DPP's office attended. Sergeant Riley appeared instead and said he could give the facts if Mr Davitt pleaded guilty. Mr Davitt, through his solicitor, said he was pleading not guilty.

Mr Davitt challenged the sergeant's right to appear. He argued that the District Court Rules gave any garda a right of audience, but the Garda Síochána Act 2005 gave that right only to the prosecuting garda. He said the rules could not override the Act, so the case should be struck out.

The District Court sent a question to the High Court by way of a consultative case stated: did Sergeant Riley have a right of audience to prosecute the case? In May 2022, Bolger J. answered no. She held that Order 6 rule 1 of the District Court Rules went beyond what the 2005 Act allowed. The DPP applied to the Supreme Court in July 2022.

The DPP accepted that the Garda Síochána (Amendment) Act 2022 has overtaken part of the High Court judgment. She argued that the rules remain open to challenge for other groups and in non-criminal cases, and that there are questions about the limits of the case stated procedure. Mr Davitt argued the issues are moot and do not meet the constitutional threshold. The Attorney General supported the DPP.

The Supreme Court held that the application raised important issues, including whether the case stated procedure is limited as the DPP suggests, the right of audience and the meaning of the 2005 Act. It said whether the case is moot is not clear cut and can be decided during the appeal.

The court plans early case management before submissions are delivered.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal