The Supreme Court refused Janet Matthews leave to appeal on 8 September 2021 in her case with the Bank of Ireland. The High Court (Justice Costello) had earlier granted the bank an order for possession of lands at Laytown, Co. Meath, and the Court of Appeal held that Ms Matthews could not rely on section 3 of the Land and Conveyancing Law Reform Act 2013.
The mortgage on the lands was entered into by John Melsop, who is now deceased, in favour of ICS Building Society, the bank's predecessor. A key question was whether Ms Matthews came within the meaning of "mortgagor" in section 3.
She argued that the term includes the personal representative of a deceased person's estate who also lives in the property as a principal private residence. The Supreme Court said it was clear that she has not taken out a grant of representation and does not intend to do so. It held that the issue therefore did not arise on the facts.
The Court noted no evidence was led in the High Court that she is entitled to an interest in the property under Mr Melsop's will. It said this was not an appropriate case in which to clarify the term.
Her second argument was about how the mortgage deed should be interpreted. The Court said the Court of Appeal had applied well-established principles to the facts and no issue of general public importance arose.
The panel was Chief Justice Clarke, Justice O'Malley and Justice Baker.