localnews.ie

Patrick McGovern refused Supreme Court appeal over widower's pension claim

By Cathal Brosnan

Historic decision · Decision date:

The Supreme Court said the issues might be narrowed in the Court of Appeal, so there were no grounds to leapfrog that court and appeal directly from the High Court.

Patrick McGovern, who lost a High Court challenge over a refused widower's pension, was refused leave to appeal directly to the Supreme Court on 1 September 2021. The Court said he had not shown the exceptional circumstances needed to bypass the Court of Appeal.

His claims for the Widowed or Surviving Civil Partner Grant and the Widower's Contributory Pension were refused after the death of Pauline Carbery in 2016. The Department said his 1994 divorce from his first wife, obtained in London, was not recognised as valid. The Chief Appeals Officer upheld those decisions.

Mr McGovern then brought judicial review proceedings against the Chief Appeals Officer, the Minister for Employment Affairs and Social Protection, Ireland and the Attorney General. He argued that EU law obliges Ireland to recognise his divorce, and made constitutional arguments, including discrimination as an Irish citizen. The High Court rejected his case.

He asked to appeal directly to the Supreme Court. He argued that an appeal to the Court of Appeal would add delay, cost and stress, and that a direct appeal would give certainty to other bereaved families.

The Supreme Court was not satisfied that the criteria for a direct appeal had been met. It said the issues might be narrowed further in the Court of Appeal, including through the case of T v L on Irish law and EU rules on family status.

The panel was Chief Justice Clarke, Justice O'Malley and Justice Baker.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal