localnews.ie

Michael Bird refused Supreme Court appeal in Start Mortgages possession case

By Fionn Kelly

Historic decision · Decision date:

The Supreme Court said many of his grounds had not been raised before the High Court judge whose decision he wanted to challenge.

The Supreme Court refused Michael Bird leave to appeal directly from the High Court in his case with Start Mortgages DAC, in a determination delivered on 26 August 2021. The Court held that his application did not meet the constitutional threshold, which requires an issue of general public importance or a need for an appeal in the interests of justice.

The case began when the Circuit Court gave Start Mortgages possession of lands that were the subject of the proceedings. The Master of the High Court extended the time within which Mr Bird could appeal that order, and Start Mortgages appealed against the Master's decision to the High Court.

The High Court decision under challenge was given ex tempore by Justice McDonald on 17 February 2020. It dealt with whether Mr Bird had arguable grounds, which are required before time to appeal can be extended under established case law.

The Supreme Court said that many of the matters Mr Bird now relied on were not raised in the High Court. It said leave cannot properly be granted from a lower court order on points that were never put to the judge who made it.

On the three points he did raise there, the Court found that Justice McDonald had simply applied well-established principles to the facts. It said none of them met the constitutional threshold.

The panel was Chief Justice Clarke, Justice O'Malley and Justice Baker.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal