The Supreme Court refused Alan Gray leave to appeal on 30 July 2021, in his case with Bank of Ireland Mortgage Bank. Neither he nor anyone on his behalf attended his appeal hearing in the Court of Appeal on 23 October 2020 or on 28 October 2020.
The High Court (Justice Meenan) had allowed the bank to recover €893,133.96 from Mr Gray on 15 August 2018. When no one appeared for him on the adjourned date, the Court of Appeal dismissed his appeal.
Mr Gray said travel restrictions during the pandemic stopped him attending on 23 October and he had no facilities at home to appear virtually. He said he was then exposed to a positive Covid-19 case. The Supreme Court said there was no indication that he had told the Court of Appeal about this.
He argued that online hearings are held in private, in breach of the Constitution, and asked for questions to be sent to the Court of Justice of the European Union.
The Supreme Court said remote hearings are not private, because any member of the public may ask for the video link code. It said he could have applied to the Court of Appeal to set aside its order or reinstate his appeal. It added that his proposed European questions concern only the Irish Constitution.
The Court held that neither constitutional test for an appeal was met. The panel was Justice MacMenamin, Justice Charleton and Justice Woulfe.