Robert Donnelly and his son Henry Donnelly, who is a minor, were granted leave to appeal to the Supreme Court on 29 July 2021 in their case against the Minister for Social Protection, Ireland and the Attorney General. The Court said their challenge concerns the equality guarantee in social welfare matters.
The Donnellys challenged a decision that the father of a severely disabled child was not entitled to domiciliary care allowance when the child was in hospital for longer than the legislation allows. They say that exclusion is unjustifiable discrimination contrary to Article 40.1 of the Constitution.
Their argument is that parents who care for a child at home are treated differently from those who spend an equivalent amount of time caring for a child in hospital. They say the second group may suffer a comparable financial loss.
The High Court (Justice Binchy) rejected their challenge. The Court of Appeal, in a judgment delivered by Justice Murray on 21 May 2021, also rejected it. The applicants argue that the Court of Appeal erred in its analysis of the constitutional guarantee of equality.
The Supreme Court held that the issues meet the constitutional criteria. It said the application of the equality guarantee in social welfare matters is of general public importance. It added that the issues raised on the facts of this case could affect other people in similar positions.
The applicants filed a proposed notice of appeal setting out 20 grounds. The Court said "this may not be a helpful approach". It asked the parties to agree a statement of issues before the first case management hearing, grouped under broad thematic headings. The panel was Chief Justice Clarke, Justice O'Malley and Justice Baker.