localnews.ie

Farrukh and Fahad Abbas refused Supreme Court appeal over residence card

By Niamh Kearney

Historic decision · Decision date:

The Supreme Court said the Court of Appeal had applied the wording of the EU directive and standard legal principles in a case about free movement rights.

The Supreme Court refused Farrukh Abbas and Fahad Abbas leave to appeal on 22 July 2021, so the Court of Appeal's ruling in their case against the Minister for Justice and Equality stands.

The brothers had challenged the Minister's refusal of Fahad Abbas's application for a residence card. He had applied on the basis that he is a permitted family member of Farrukh Abbas under the Free Movement of Persons Regulations 2015. The Minister refused the application on 13 November 2018.

The Minister said living with his brother in Ireland did not make him part of an EU citizen's household. The Minister also found the proof of dependency inadequate.

The Court of Appeal held that membership of an EU citizen's household must relate to the country from which a person has come. The brothers argued that a household can be formed in Ireland and engages free movement. They also said refusing to recognise dependency defied reason and common sense.

The Supreme Court found no error in the Court of Appeal's analysis, which rested on the wording of the Directive. It said the Court of Appeal had applied standard principles on the dependency decision. The case met neither test for an appeal.

The panel was Justice MacMenamin, Justice Charleton and Justice Baker.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal