Pádraig Higgins has been granted leave by the Supreme Court to appeal the reduction of his defamation award on 22 July 2021.
The case arose from emails sent by the Irish Aviation Authority after Higgins and a friend flew microlight aircraft from Italy to Ireland in April 2013. After an unexpected stop in England, one aircraft sustained minor damage. The Authority’s correspondence raised queries about whether the flight was authorised and complied with regulations. The determination records that the legal requirements had apparently been met.
Higgins uncovered the emails after making information requests because he was concerned about his career. He then brought defamation proceedings. The Authority made an offer of amends, admitting liability, but the parties did not resolve the form it should take. A jury assessed damages at €300,000 in the High Court. The Court of Appeal reduced that sum to €70,000 and applied a 10 per cent discount for the offer of amends.
Higgins argued that the Court of Appeal had no authority to interfere with the jury’s award. The Authority maintained that the reduction was warranted. The Supreme Court said the case raised issues of general public importance about how juries should be instructed on defamation damages and when an award can be overturned on appeal. It also identified questions about discounts for offers of amends and whether guidance or bands for awards could be set out.
The Supreme Court granted Higgins leave to appeal from the Court of Appeal. That decision permits an appeal to proceed; the determination does not decide the appeal on its merits.
The determination lists MacMenamin, Charleton and Woulfe JJ as the Supreme Court panel.