The Supreme Court granted Vincent Banks leave to appeal his conviction for membership of an unlawful organisation on 22 July 2021. The Court of Appeal had upheld the conviction. Mr Banks asked the Supreme Court to hear a further appeal. He raised three issues. The Court granted leave on two and refused it on one.
The first issue concerns his arrests. He was arrested twice, about three months apart, under section 30 of the Offences Against the State Act 1939. Both arrests were on suspicion of membership. Mr Banks says the second arrest was unlawful. He says gardaí did not apply to the District Court for a warrant under section 30A.
The Special Criminal Court and the Court of Appeal found the second arrest lawful. They said new circumstances and new information arose after the first arrest. The Supreme Court said this issue is one of public importance.
The third issue concerns a Detective Chief Superintendent. He gave evidence of his belief that Mr Banks belonged to an unlawful organisation. Mr Banks says the witness claimed privilege so broadly that effective cross-examination was impossible. The Court granted leave on this issue too.
It warned the parties that a pending decision in People (DPP) v Cassidy may overtake the point. Any effect can be dealt with in case management.
The second issue was the explanation of section 2 of the Act that gardaí gave him in interview. The Court said this was a matter of fact for the trial court, which the Court of Appeal had reviewed. It said correcting errors is not its role. The panel was Justice O'Donnell, Justice Charleton and Justice O'Malley.