The Supreme Court refused Cheng Zhang leave to appeal on 15 July 2021, in her personal injuries case against Stephen Farrell. The Court of Appeal had already reduced her share of the blame to 20% and awarded her €372,420.80.
The High Court had found Mr Farrell 55% liable and Ms Zhang 45% liable, and awarded €265,039.30. She was struck by his car in Dublin City in 2011.
Ms Zhang argued that the courts used inappropriate factors in assessing damages. She said she had been unable to finish her studies to become a Chartered Accountant and was not fully compensated for the career she lost. She also criticised the trial judge's approach to the possibility of her marrying and having a family.
Mr Farrell opposed her application. He said the evidence that she crossed at a pedestrian crossing on a red light was uncontroverted.
The Supreme Court accepted that she was in a serious road traffic accident that had a significant effect on her physically and mentally. It said an appeal could not be granted merely to correct errors.
It found that the Court of Appeal had carefully considered liability and the amount of damages, and had followed the evidence. It held that no issue of general public importance arose and the interests of justice did not require a further appeal. The panel was Justice Dunne, Justice O'Malley and Justice Baker.