localnews.ie

Cheng Zhang refused Supreme Court appeal over new evidence in injury claim

By Eimear Byrne

Historic decision · Decision date:

She wanted to challenge a Court of Appeal judge's refusal to admit updated medical and actuarial reports in her claim over being struck by a car in Dublin.

The Supreme Court refused Cheng Zhang leave to appeal on 15 July 2021, in her personal injuries case against Stephen Farrell. She was struck by his car in Dublin City in 2011.

The High Court found Mr Farrell 55% liable and Ms Zhang 45% liable. It awarded her damages of €265,039.30 on that apportioned basis.

Ms Zhang appealed. Before the full hearing, she asked the Court of Appeal to admit new evidence, including an updated actuarial report and updated medical and psychiatric reports. Justice Costello refused that request on 30 October 2020, finding she had not met the test for admitting new evidence.

The full appeal went ahead without those reports. The Court of Appeal found Mr Farrell 80% liable and Ms Zhang 20% liable, but did not change the amount of damages. Ms Zhang asked the Supreme Court to hear an appeal against the refusal to admit the reports. Mr Farrell opposed her application.

The Supreme Court said the rules on admitting new evidence on appeal are long established and clear. It said evidence cannot be added on appeal to improve a party's position.

It found she had met neither test for an appeal, and noted that she had improved her position on liability in the Court of Appeal. The panel was Justice Dunne, Justice O'Malley and Justice Baker.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal