Pat Wheelock has been granted leave to cross-appeal to the Supreme Court over costs in a dispute about disclosure of a loan purchase price, following a determination on 12 July 2021. The court also granted leave to Promontoria (Arrow) Limited and Stephen Tennant to appeal the discovery order.
The dispute arose from proceedings concerning loans and mortgages secured on lands in Monvoy, Waterford. Wheelock claimed that documents connected with the receivership were void because the mortgage deeds and their registration had relied on instruments of fraud or had been induced by mistake. Promontoria and Tennant counterclaimed, alleging that Wheelock had been unjustly enriched because the land had increased in value.
Wheelock sought discovery of 15 categories of documents. Category 13 asked for documents recording the price paid by Promontoria to acquire the loan facility or mortgage deeds. The Court of Appeal ordered discovery of those documents, finding the purchase price relevant and necessary. It overturned an earlier High Court decision, which had found that the discovery should not be ordered. The Court of Appeal made no order for costs.
Promontoria and Tennant sought leave to challenge the discovery ruling, arguing that the price was commercially sensitive and not needed for a fair trial. They also raised concerns about restrictions on who could inspect the documents and how the price could be disclosed. Wheelock opposed their application and sought leave to cross-appeal the costs decision.
The Supreme Court said the issues raised could affect discovery, unjust enrichment and the disclosure obligations of investment funds to debtors. It found that the appeal was warranted in the interests of justice, including because the obligations to disclose purchase prices and conditions on viewing that information required consideration.
The court granted leave to appeal to Promontoria and Tennant, and leave to cross-appeal to Wheelock, subject to further refinement of the issues at case management. The cross-appeal on costs is to be considered further at a case management hearing.