The Supreme Court on 25 January 2021 granted Michael Wymes leave to appeal against the Court of Appeal's decision upholding his adjudication as a bankrupt. The petition was brought by the Minister for Communications, Energy and Natural Resources, with Michael O'Connell.
Meenan J adjudicated Mr Wymes bankrupt on 23 March 2018. The petition had issued on 11 June 2010, many years earlier, and the Minister had been restrained from acting on it while an appeal was pending in the Supreme Court.
On 31 May 2018 Mr Wymes filed a Notice to Show Cause against the adjudication under section 16 of the Bankruptcy Act 1988. He argued that no act of bankruptcy had occurred in the three months before the petition, because the validity of the bankruptcy summons had not yet been finally decided.
Pilkington J rejected his arguments. On 6 October 2020 the Court of Appeal dismissed his appeal in a judgment by Faherty J, with Kennedy J and Ní Raifeartaigh J agreeing. It held that a valid petition had been submitted in time, so an act of bankruptcy could occur by failure to pay on foot of the summons.
Mr Wymes submits that sections 8(5) and 11(1)(c) of the 1988 Act are ambiguous and that an act of bankruptcy cannot occur during a challenge to a bankruptcy summons. The Minister says the law is clear and that to hold otherwise would allow the recipient of a summons to prevent an act of bankruptcy simply by challenging it.
The Minister also said the underlying debt was determined some 34 years ago and remains wholly undischarged.
The Supreme Court found a matter of general public importance: the effect of an application to dismiss a bankruptcy summons, and whether an act of bankruptcy can occur on a failure to pay a summons whose validity is undetermined. It said the consequences of bankruptcy are so far-reaching that the interests of justice require clarity on the basis of adjudication.
His other grounds did not meet the constitutional tests. Mr Wymes asked for a priority hearing because of his advanced age and ill health. The court said a formal order was not necessary and expects the case to be heard in the normal course without significant delay.
The court recommended that he contact the Registrar about a scheme offering voluntary legal representation. The issues may be refined at case management. The determination was made by MacMenamin J, O'Malley J and Baker J.