localnews.ie

Andrius Sciuka granted appeal over surrender postponement

By Saoirse Doyle

Historic decision · Decision date:

The Supreme Court granted leave to appeal over a COVID-19-related delay to his surrender to Lithuania.

Andrius Sciuka was granted leave to appeal by the Supreme Court on 9 July 2021 over the postponement of his surrender to Lithuania under a European Arrest Warrant.

The Court of Appeal had dismissed the Minister for Justice and Equality’s appeal against a High Court order postponing surrender on humanitarian grounds. That order followed a request from Lithuania to extend the handover deadline after flights from Ireland and the United Kingdom were cancelled amid COVID-19 restrictions.

The warrant sought Sciuka’s surrender to serve the remainder of a seven-year prison sentence imposed for armed robbery and illegal possession of firearms. The determination records that two years, eight months and 12 days remained to be served.

Sciuka argued that the High Court lacked evidence of humanitarian grounds and that the application should have been brought under a different provision of the European Arrest Warrant Act 2003. The Court of Appeal concluded that the humanitarian provisions applied and that the High Court had correctly applied the law and proportionality when setting the postponement period.

The Supreme Court said the issues about the scope of humanitarian grounds and the operation of the surrender procedure were matters of general public importance. It identified the reach of the statutory provision and whether the High Court was right to postpone surrender in the pandemic circumstances as issues for the appeal.

The decision grants permission to bring the appeal; it does not determine those issues. The Court noted that the postponement had ended in March 2021, after the High Court found the circumstances no longer existed.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal