localnews.ie

Herlihy Supermarket Group refused Supreme Court appeal over Cian McCarthy injuries

By Aoife Loughran

Historic decision · Decision date:

Tekken Security also failed in its bid to appeal a ruling that a supermarket and its security firm owed a duty of care to a man assaulted outside the shop.

The Supreme Court refused James Kavanagh, trading as Tekken Security, and Herlihy Supermarket Group leave to appeal on 6 July 2021. They wanted to appeal a Court of Appeal order dismissing their challenge to an award of damages to Cian McCarthy.

On 31 October 2011 Mr McCarthy was removed from the supermarket by two security staff after a dispute about queue jumping.

Three patrons followed him outside and assaulted him, and a security guard refused to let him back into the shop. He was then punched by another man and suffered severe injuries, including brain damage.

The High Court found the defendants owed him a duty of care and awarded him damages for negligence and breach of duty. The Court of Appeal upheld that decision, finding the failure was the refusal to readmit him.

The Supreme Court said that ruling was rooted in its own facts and did not restate or extend the law of negligence. It found no matter of general public interest and no need for an appeal in the interests of justice.

It also noted that Mr McCarthy had obtained default judgment against his assailant. The panel was Justice Dunne, Justice O'Malley and Justice Baker.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal