The Supreme Court refused Arnaud D Gaultier leave to appeal on 6 July 2021, in his case against the Revenue Commissioners, the Minister for Finance, the Courts Service, the Minister for Justice, Ireland and the Attorney General. He had earlier brought proceedings against the Registrar of Companies after his company, Loire Valley Ltd, was struck off in 2012. The High Court dismissed them on 8 March 2013, and again on 6 July 2017.
Mr Gaultier then asked the Court of Appeal to adjourn his appeals until judges could be held accountable before an independent body. He also sought declarations on a section of the Judicial Council Act 2019. The Court of Appeal found the adjournment request without merit and awarded costs against him on 8 April 2021.
He argued that a section of the 2019 Act, which had not yet been commenced, raised questions about the courts' authority to decide cases. His application was late, and the respondents did not oppose an extension of time.
The Supreme Court called the application misconceived. It said the Court of Appeal decision was interlocutory, in an area of judicial discretion where leave is seldom granted. It said he did not claim actual bias by any judge, so his case was premature and hypothetical.
The Court found no issue of general public importance and no evidence of bias or misconduct. The panel was Justice O'Donnell, Justice MacMenamin and Justice Charleton.