The Supreme Court refused Angela Pearce leave to appeal directly from the High Court on 5 July 2021, in her case against An Bord Pleanála over a quarry. Her earlier challenges to the quarry's planning history had already failed or been struck out.
The High Court rejected her challenge in 2009 to a direction that the quarry apply for planning permission, and she withdrew her appeal. After An Bord Pleanála granted permission on 15 July 2009, her judicial review proceedings to quash it were struck out.
The present case arose after the Board decided on 23 March 2014 to set aside a requirement that the quarry apply for substitute consent. Ms Pearce argued that the Board should have examined whether the 2009 environmental impact assessment was valid.
The High Court found that she was making an impermissible collateral attack on the earlier permission. The Supreme Court said she had misunderstood that finding.
It said the environmental impact statement was accepted as valid at the time. She had a chance to challenge it then and was unsuccessful, so she could not reopen it. It added that many of her grounds were unparticularised assertions that the judge erred.
The panel was Justice Dunne, Justice O'Malley and Justice Baker.