Tibor Baranya has been granted leave by the Supreme Court to appeal a High Court decision on whether his workplace complaint was a protected disclosure, in a determination dated 2 July 2021.
The application concerns Baranya’s claim that Rosderra Irish Meats Group Limited unfairly dismissed him for raising concerns about pain caused by his work. He sought leave to appeal directly from the High Court, arguing that the case raised a matter of general public importance about what communication can qualify as a protected disclosure under the Protected Disclosures Act 2014.
The Supreme Court, comprising O’Donnell, MacMenamin and Woulfe JJ, found that the interpretation of the Act raised an issue of general public importance. It said clarity would be in the public interest and that the issue could arise in future proceedings. The Court also noted a difference between the Circuit Court’s view and those of the Labour Court and High Court on whether Baranya’s communication was, or could be, a protected disclosure.
The Court found exceptional circumstances for allowing a direct appeal, noting that no appeal from the High Court decision would lie unless the Supreme Court permitted one, and that the outcome could provide legal certainty in an area affecting the rights of many people. It therefore granted leave to appeal.
This determination decides the application for leave. The substantive appeal remains to be heard; the Supreme Court has not ruled here on whether Baranya’s communication was a protected disclosure.
The High Court had dismissed Baranya’s appeal on a point of law from the Labour Court, which had upheld the rejection of his unfair dismissal complaint. The High Court decision followed the Labour Court’s conclusion that his communication—that he wanted to change roles because he was in pain—was a grievance about health and safety, rather than a disclosure of wrongdoing.