The Supreme Court on 25 January 2021 refused Seamus Downes leave to appeal in his case with National Asset Loan Management Limited and Promontoria (GEM) Designated Activity Company. He challenged a Court of Appeal refusal to admit fresh evidence.
On 16 January 2014 the High Court (Charleton J) found money owing by Mr Downes in two proceedings, one as a borrower and one as a guarantor of the debts of Mount Kennett Investment Ltd.
Mr Downes asked the Court of Appeal to admit seven categories of new documents. Costello J, refused the application on 25 September 2020, and the order followed on 15 October 2020.
He sought leave to appeal that refusal for two categories. They are loan statements and an AIB certificate of loan drawdown.
He argued that borrowers and guarantors should be able to rely on loan statements that surface only at appeal stage. The respondents said he had the certificate at trial and could have obtained the statements with reasonable diligence.
The Supreme Court said he did not claim the judge ignored established principles but that she misapplied them. It does not correct errors within jurisdiction, so no matter of general public importance arose.
He did not explain why Costello J was wrong to find he could have obtained the statements, including by discovery, or that he had the certificate and chose not to use it. The interests of justice test was not met.
The determination was made by Clarke CJ, O'Malley J and Baker J.