The Supreme Court has granted the Minister for Education and Skills leave to appeal in the case of Elijah Burke, a home-schooled Leaving Certificate student. The determination was delivered on 15 June 2021. The case concerns the Calculated Grades Scheme set up in 2020 because the pandemic made Leaving Certificate exams unlikely. Elijah Burke was educated at home under a registered teacher. The scheme excluded marks from teachers with a family relationship to the candidate.
Schools had a substitute assessment mechanism in such cases, but home-schooled candidates did not. The High Court (Justice Meenan) held on 19 August 2020 that excluding the candidate was unreasonable and invalid. The Court of Appeal dismissed the Minister's appeal on 9 March 2021.
The Court of Appeal treated the scheme as an exercise of executive power. It found that the decision affected the candidate's constitutionally protected right to be home-schooled. It held that the exclusion was unreasonable and disproportionate.
The Supreme Court noted that the proceedings are arguably moot, as the candidate has since received calculated grades. The Minister does not seek to disturb the costs orders in the candidate's favour. The candidate agreed that the case still raises issues that need to be decided.
The Court found that the case raises issues of general public importance, both for the scheme and for administrative and constitutional law. These include the nature of the power used to set up the scheme, the proper test for challenging it, and whether the Court of Appeal could take later events into account.
The appeal will be heard together with a companion case, NP v The Minister for Education, involving a home-schooled candidate whose tutors were not registered teachers. Time was extended for the application, which was filed late. The panel was Justice O'Donnell, Justice MacMenamin and Justice Charleton.