localnews.ie

John Tobin granted Supreme Court appeal in Revenue bankruptcy summons case

By Ruairí Dolan

Historic decision · Decision date:

The Supreme Court will decide whether a bankruptcy summons must be dismissed if it overstates the debt, even when much more than the €20,000 threshold is owed.

The Supreme Court has granted John Tobin leave to appeal in a bankruptcy case taken against him over a Revenue demand of €405,808.66. The determination was delivered on 14 June 2021. Michael Gladney issued the bankruptcy summons against Mr Tobin. It stated that he had 14 days to dispute the demand. He did not do so and raised the issue about six months later.

The Revenue said that, however the figures were viewed, more than €330,000 was due. It said Mr Tobin's claim to a VAT rebate of €71,030 was not founded in a realistic or credible way. In its view, any overstatement did not matter.

The Court of Appeal ruled for the Revenue on 3 March 2020, in a judgment by Justice Collins. That court decided the case on whether Mr Tobin had a credible defence. Justice Collins nonetheless said the point on overstated claims was important and could create an anomaly. He said the court rules on bankruptcy summonses might need urgent review.

The Supreme Court found that an issue of general public importance had been identified, given the prominence of the bankruptcy code in modern insolvency. It said two other points also had to be decided before the appeal could be resolved. These are the threshold of credibility for disputing a sum and the failure to raise the defence in time.

The Court set out three questions, subject to case management. The first is whether any overstatement of a debt in a bankruptcy summons means the petition is dismissed, or whether it is enough that at least €20,000 is due. The second is what credibility a debtor must show to dispute an overstated sum. The third is whether failing to assert a defence in time is fatal to it.

The panel was Justice O'Donnell, Justice MacMenamin and Justice Charleton.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal