The Supreme Court refused Catherine Gaffney leave to appeal on 25 May 2021 in a case brought by the Minister for Justice and Equality under the European Arrest Warrant Act 2003. She had wanted to appeal a ruling that the High Court cannot grant her bail.
An order had been made for Ms Gaffney's surrender to the UK to face trial for theft offences. That order was postponed because she is serving a prison sentence in this State. She sought bail so she could attend a Community Return programme, which helps people with a history of addiction to re-integrate into the community.
The High Court and the Court of Appeal both held that section 27(2) of the Act removes the High Court's power to grant bail to a person sentenced to imprisonment in the State. Ms Gaffney argued that the section should be read in line with an earlier Supreme Court decision, Butenas, on a different section of the Act.
The Supreme Court said the issues could have some significance in a suitable case. It found, however, that "the issues are in fact moot", because she was no longer detained in custody. Her sentence was also due to expire in June 2021, before any possible hearing.
The panel was Justice MacMenamin, Justice Dunne and Justice Baker.