The Supreme Court refused Giles Kennedy leave to appeal on 18 May 2021, so the strike-out of his challenge to a road traffic law stands. His case was against the Director of Public Prosecutions, Ireland and the Attorney General.
Mr Kennedy was convicted in the District Court in April 2011 of failing to provide a breath sample under section 12(3) of the Road Traffic Act 1994. He was acquitted of a second offence. The Circuit Court upheld the conviction in May 2016.
He said degenerative hearing loss stopped him hearing the arresting garda. The Circuit Court judge found his hearing loss was not such as to give him a defence.
He then challenged section 12(3) on constitutional and European Convention grounds. The High Court struck out his case because he lacked standing, and the Court of Appeal dismissed his appeal.
The Supreme Court said the law on standing is well established and no general public interest arises. It stressed that he had been found not to have a hearing disability that would have given him a defence.
It also said his argument about when such a challenge must be brought did not justify an appeal. Even if it had succeeded, he would still have faced the Circuit Court's findings. The panel was Chief Justice Clarke, Justice O'Donnell and Justice Baker.