The Supreme Court has granted Aidan Conroy leave to appeal against his drugs conviction, in a determination dated 12 May 2021. The Court said significant issues arise about how a law on uncorroborated confessions applies in cases of this kind.
Mr Conroy is a self-employed haulier. He arrived at Dublin Port on 20 August 2015 with a cargo of fruit. Customs officers searched his vehicle and found controlled drugs hidden in a fire extinguisher in the cab of his lorry.
One officer gave evidence that Mr Conroy said "so you found the drugs then" as they walked towards the cab. The other officer did not hear this. Drugs were also found in the trailer. Mr Conroy was arrested and denied any knowledge of the drugs and denied making the remark.
The trial heard argument on whether the alleged admission was admissible, and on whether he should have been cautioned. The evidence was admitted. The jury convicted him on the charges relating to the drugs in the cab and acquitted him on those relating to the trailer.
Neither counsel nor the trial judge raised section 10 of the Criminal Procedure Act 1993, which requires a judge to give a jury particular advice in a case involving an uncorroborated confession. The Court of Appeal allowed Mr Conroy to raise this as a new ground of appeal. It rejected that ground and his other arguments in a ruling on 30 November 2020.
The Court of Appeal relied on an earlier Supreme Court decision, DPP v Power. It concluded that no special warning was required where the fact of making a confession was in issue. The panel was Chief Justice Clarke, Justice O'Malley and Justice Baker.