localnews.ie

Shardha Sobhy maternity benefit case goes to Supreme Court on State appeal

By Tadhg O'Sullivan

Historic decision · Decision date:

The State will appeal directly from the High Court, which had sent the maternity benefit decision back to the Chief Appeals Officer for reconsideration.

The Supreme Court has granted the State leave to appeal directly from the High Court in the case of Shardha Sobhy, a dispute over maternity benefit. The determination was delivered on 11 May 2021.

The applicants for leave were the Chief Appeals Officer, the Minister for Employment Affairs and Social Protection, Ireland and the Attorney General. Shardha Sobhy did not oppose the application. The Human Rights and Equality Commission is a notice party.

The central issue is the status, for social welfare purposes, of an employment contract that may be unlawful because of the immigration status of the person employed. The High Court found in favour of Shardha Sobhy on 11 February 2021. It sent the matter back to the Chief Appeals Officer, who had disallowed maternity benefit, to reconsider under the principles in its judgment.

The Supreme Court said the question was one of general public importance. Shardha Sobhy came to Ireland lawfully, but that status changed as a result of legal developments. It appeared to be accepted that the contract of employment was therefore unlawful at the material times. The impact of that on the status of PRSI payments made by the employer and the employee goes beyond the facts of this case, the Court said.

The Court also agreed that a direct appeal was justified. It said the case would look the same whether it came straight from the High Court or after an appeal to the Court of Appeal. It added that there is merit in bringing clarity to the legal issue as soon as practicable.

An appeal in similar form has also been filed in the Court of Appeal. By law, that appeal will be discontinued automatically now that leave for the direct appeal has been granted. The panel was Chief Justice Clarke, Justice O'Malley and Justice Baker.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal