The Supreme Court refused Flannán Collins leave to appeal against the Court of Appeal on 11 May 2021. The case was brought by Ulster Bank Ireland Limited, with Cabot Financial (Ireland) Limited joined to it by order of the Court of Appeal.
Mr Collins was a director and major investor in Tara Hill National Park Teoranta. He guaranteed its liabilities to Ulster Bank under an agreement dated 5 March 2007. Judgment of €54,314.39 was entered against the company on 1 August 2012 and was not appealed. The bank then sued Mr Collins on the guarantee.
The High Court rejected his defences. The Court of Appeal accepted proof of a principal sum of €52,727.50 owed by him, but was not satisfied that the claim for contractual interest was made out.
Mr Collins asked the Supreme Court to look at mathematical formulae which he said showed improper accounting practices by banks. He said Ulster Bank owed him €435,491.
The Supreme Court said those methods had no bearing on his liability unless they caused a miscalculation of the sum due under the guarantee, and that had not been shown. It found no matter of general public importance and no need for an appeal in the interests of justice. It also saw no basis for sending questions to the Court of Justice of the European Union.
The panel was Justice MacMenamin, Justice Dunne and Justice Woulfe.