localnews.ie

Michael Murphy wins Supreme Court appeal leave on judge recusal

By Eimear Byrne

Historic decision · Decision date:

The Supreme Court granted leave to appeal over whether the judge should recuse himself from Murphy’s retrial.

Michael Murphy won leave to appeal to the Supreme Court on 10 May 2021 over a trial judge’s refusal to recuse himself from a retrial on diesel laundering charges.

The Supreme Court granted leave to appeal from the Court of Appeal. That decision allows the appeal to proceed; it does not decide its merits. The court said the appeal would be listed for case management at an early date, with the issues to be refined then.

The application concerned the judge who had presided over Murphy’s first trial. During a voir dire, a hearing about whether prosecution evidence could be admitted, the judge rejected defence applications in strong terms and made adverse comments to the defence. The jury disagreed, and a retrial was pending.

Murphy sought the judge’s recusal, arguing that his earlier findings and impressions could influence how he assessed evidence in the retrial. The Circuit Court judge refused to step aside. Murphy then sought judicial review, asking the High Court to quash decisions made by that judge.

The High Court refused the order. It held that the circumstances did not meet the test for objective bias and that the jury remained the ultimate arbiter of guilt or innocence. The Court of Appeal dismissed Murphy’s appeal, finding insufficient basis for the relief sought.

In granting leave, the Supreme Court said the case raised issues of general public importance about objective bias and the integrity of the trial process. It said the legal principles governing recusal applications in these circumstances warranted consideration. The court was composed of MacMenamin, Dunne and Woulfe JJ.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal